My Favorite Flop

You’ll Shoot Your Eye Out!

December 29, 2020

“It all comes down to Christmas” as hosts Bobby and Kristina discuss 2012’s A Christmas Story: The Musical on My Favorite Flop’s out-of-town, limited-edition Christmas Special.



Based on the popular 1983 film, A Christmas Story: The Musical tells the story of Ralphie Parker, a child in 1940s Indiana, who desperately wants a Red Ryder BB Gun for Christmas. After numerous regional productions, out-of-town tryouts, and national tours, the musical finally opened on Broadway for a limited engagement in 2012. The show features a book by Joseph Robinette with music and lyrics by Benj Pasek and Justin Paul.

The Broadway production cost $9.5 million dollars to produce, making it impossible to pay back investors during the show's limited engagement — officially earning its status as a “flop.” Despite its "failure" on The Great White Way, A Christmas Story: The Musical has continued to tour across America, remain popular in the regional market, and was even adapted for television in 2017.


Original Broadway Cast

  • Johnny Rabe/Joe West as Ralphie Parker
  • Zac Ballard as Randy Parker
  • Dan Lauria as Jean Shepherd
  • Erin Dilly as Mother
  • John Bolton as The Old Man
  • Caroline O’Connor as Miss Shields
  • J.D. Rodriguez as Schwartz
  • Jeremy Shinder as Flick
  • Jack Mastrianni as Scut Farkus
  • John Francis Babbo as Grover Dill
  • Analise Scarpaci as Esther Jane
  • Beatrice Tulchin as Mary Beth
  • Eddie Korbich as Santa
  • Kirsten Wyatt as Mrs. Schwartz
  • Andrew Cristi as Restaurant Waiter

Podbean App

Play this podcast on Podbean App